January Is the Most Expensive Month to Skip Insurance Re-Verification

    Why January costs more than any other month

    Picture the front desk on Monday, January 4, 2027. The schedule is full. Some families changed jobs over the fall, some picked a new plan during open enrollment, and some have a new insurance card still sitting unopened on the kitchen counter. They all walk in expecting the same visit, at the same cost, as in December.

    For a lot of them it won't be the same. On January 1, deductibles reset, employer plans change, and some Medicare and Medicaid members move to a new plan or a new set of rules. None of that shows on the schedule. It shows up weeks later, as denials and as bills families didn't expect.

    The fix isn't exciting, and it has a deadline. Re-verify everyone on the January schedule in December, against the plan they will have on January 1. This isn't the routine eligibility check you run before each visit. That check tells you coverage is active. This one tells you what changed.

    What changes on January 1, 2027

    Deductibles reset, and they keep climbing

    Most commercial plans reset the deductible on January 1. In KFF's 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey, the average deductible for single coverage was $1,955 among workers whose plan has a general deductible, and $2,624 at firms with 10 to 199 workers. 38% of covered workers now have a single-coverage deductible of $2,000 or more.

    So a family that had met its deductible by December can owe the full contracted rate for the same session on January 4. If nobody tells them first, they find out from the statement.

    Employers are changing plans again

    Employers expect total health benefit cost per employee to rise 8.2% in 2027, the biggest increase since 2003, according to preliminary results from Marsh's 2026 National Survey of Employer-Sponsored Health Plans (more than 1,800 employers, released September 2, 2026). 59% plan cost-cutting changes for 2027, including plan design changes such as higher deductibles.

    At the front desk, that looks like a new group number, a different network, or a different company managing the behavioral health benefit. Often the patient doesn't know yet.

    Medicare Advantage switches take effect

    Plan choices made during Medicare open enrollment (October 15 to December 7) take effect on January 1. Then Medicare Advantage members get one more chance to switch, between January 1 and March 31. For PT and OT practices with older patients, the January plan isn't always the December plan. It may not be the April plan either.

    Medicaid renewals get more frequent for expansion adults

    The federal law passed in July 2025 (H.R. 1, Section 71107) requires states to renew Medicaid eligibility every six months, instead of every 12, for most adults in the expansion group. It starts with renewals scheduled on or after January 1, 2027 (CMS letter SMD #26-001). Expansion states also have to start the new community engagement requirement for adults aged 19 to 64 by January 1, 2027, unless CMS gives the state more time.

    Children are not part of the six-month change, so most ABA caseloads won't feel it directly. PT, OT and speech practices with adult Medicaid patients will: twice as many renewals a year, and more chances for coverage to lapse between visits.

    What a missed re-verification costs

    The denial shows up weeks after the session. In Experian Health's 2026 State of Claims survey of 204 provider finance, billing and claims staff, 40% said 10% or more of their claims are denied. That's about where it was in 2025 (41%), and up from 31% in 2022. For the first time, "services not covered" was the most-cited reason for denials: 53% put it in their top three. Frequently changing payer policies came second (31%), and difficulty obtaining prior authorization tied for third (25%).

    Read that list with January in mind. A service the new plan doesn't cover. A payer whose rules changed on January 1. An authorization the new plan requires that nobody requested. Those are the claims a December re-verification is meant to catch.

    A denied January claim isn't only rework, either. The session already happened. The family gets a bill they didn't see coming. And the authorization question that should have been settled before the first visit now has to be fixed after the fact.

    The December playbook

    • First week of December: pull the January schedule. Flag patients on employer plans that renew January 1, Medicare Advantage members, adults on Medicaid, and anyone with secondary coverage.
    • Second and third weeks: re-verify in batches. Run the eligibility check for every January patient, then look at benefits by CPT code and place of service. "Active" isn't the answer you need. Save phone calls for the cases the portal can't answer.
    • Third week: check authorizations that cross January 1. A new plan usually means a new authorization, and a new benefit year can restart visit or hour limits.
    • Last week of December: talk to families. Tell them what they'll owe before the first January session, not after it.
    • Through January: check again at scheduling. Late employer decisions and the first payroll of the year can change coverage after you checked.

    What your front desk can say

    The most common January answer is "I haven't gotten my new card yet." A reply that helps: "That's normal. Your coverage is usually active in your plan's system before the card arrives. Can you check your plan's app or member portal for your new member ID and group number?"

    For the deductible: "We checked your 2027 benefits. Your deductible reset on January 1, so until you meet it, you'll pay the contracted rate for each session. We wanted you to hear it from us before the first visit, not from the statement."

    Frequently asked questions

    Isn't the eligibility check we run before each visit enough in January?

    It tells you coverage is active. It doesn't always tell you what changed: a new plan or group number, a deductible that reset, different benefits by CPT code, or a new authorization rule. The January re-verification checks all of that against the plan the patient has on January 1.

    When should we start re-verifying for January?

    In the first week of December. That leaves time to re-verify in batches, chase the exceptions by phone and talk to families before the first January session. Keep checking at scheduling through January, because some plan changes land late.

    What do we do when a patient hasn't received their new insurance card?

    Ask them to check their plan's app or member portal, or their HR team, for the new member ID and group number, and run the eligibility check against those. Coverage is usually active in the plan's system before the card arrives.

    Do the six-month Medicaid renewals apply to children in ABA?

    No. CMS letter SMD #26-001 applies six-month renewals to most adults in the Medicaid expansion group, starting with renewals scheduled on or after January 1, 2027. Children are not part of this change. Adult Medicaid patients in PT, OT and speech are the ones most affected.

    If an adult patient's Medicaid lapses in 2027, can the coverage be backdated?

    Only by a little. For applications made on or after January 1, 2027, adults in the Medicaid expansion group can get at most one month of retroactive eligibility before the month they apply (Section 71112, as described in CMS letter SMD #26-001). A lapse caught early is much easier to fix than one caught at billing.

    How high are deductibles going into 2027?

    KFF's 2026 survey put the average single deductible at $1,955 for workers whose plan has a general deductible, and $2,624 at firms with 10 to 199 workers. 2027 figures aren't out yet, but 59% of employers in Marsh's preliminary survey plan cost-cutting changes for 2027, including plan design changes such as higher deductibles.

    Start in December

    Every January change lands on the same day, and the claims that carry them go out in the same few weeks. That's what makes January expensive. Practices that treat the December re-check as revenue work, not paperwork, and finish it before January 4 start Q1 knowing what changed. For the step-by-step version, with the differences for ABA, PT and OT, use our January 2027 re-verification checklist.

    If you'd rather not run it by hand: Annie runs benefit checks by CPT code for your whole January schedule and tracks the authorizations that cross the new year. Book a demo to see it on your own payer mix.

    Sources

    JP Montoya

    JP Montoya

    Founder & CEO, Solum Health · Forbes Technology Council Member · Speaker on Healthcare AI

    JP Montoya builds and scales healthcare administrative automation at Solum Health, working with ABA, PT, ST/OT, and other therapy practices across 40+ states. A Forbes Technology Council member and speaker on healthcare AI, he writes about healthcare operations, AI implementation, and practice management from direct experience building and running clinical workflows.

    Ready to Automate Your Front Office?

    Let Annie run your benefit checks and authorizations.

    HIPAA Business Associate
    SOC 2 Type II
    Pen Tested
    AES-256 Encrypted